Scientists are proposing a way to interpret the
initial, feeble tremors that herald the arrival of a
large earthquake that would give Orange County and other
Southern California residents advance warning of more
violent shaking to come.
The system could give tens of seconds of advance
notice - enough time to send schoolchildren diving below
their desks or to cut the flow of gas through pipelines
vulnerable to rupture, scientists said.
Details appear today in the journal Science.
The system would not predict or forecast earthquakes.
Instead, it would exploit the staggered way that energy
travels from the underground source of quakes to the
surface.
The first indication at the surface that a large
earthquake has occurred is typically the jolt caused by
the arrival of a fast-moving but low-energy wave called
the primary, or P, wave. It is followed by the more
energetic but slower-moving shear, or S, wave, which
causes far more violent shaking.
Richard Allen of the University of Wisconsin-Madison
and Hiroo Kanamori of the California Institute of
Technology developed a way to determine the location,
origin, time and - most importantly - magnitude of an
earthquake from as little as four seconds of
measurements of the frequency of the energy in the P
wave. The system would rely on a network of seismic
instruments already deployed across the region.
"If we can detect this P wave and use the information
contained in it to estimate the hazard associated with
an earthquake, then there is the potential to issue a
warning before any significant ground motion reaches the
surface," Allen said.
THE FARTHER AWAY FROM THE EPICENTER, THE MORE
WARNING
The amount of forewarning would depend on the
distance of the sensors from an earthquake's
epicenter.
If directly above the epicenter, there would be no
time for a warning, since the S wave would arrive almost
immediately after the P wave. At 37 miles from the
epicenter of a major quake, the system could give a
magnitude estimate 20 seconds before the arrival of the
S wave and the strong ground motion that accompanies it,
Allen said.
A similar system is already in use in Japan, where
individual sensors are used to provide early warnings.
Following the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake that rocked
the San Francisco Bay area, seismologists tracked P
waves to warn rescue workers on a section of collapsed
freeway about oncoming aftershocks. A Nevada company has
sold siren devices triggered by P waves to several fire
stations in California.
Such a system would allow a utility to quickly cut
power to its grid, minimizing but not eliminating
damage, said Philip Mo, a structural engineer with
Southern California Edison.
With enough warning, fire officials might move
vehicles out of their stations to avoid damage from
building collapse, said Capt. Stephen Miller of the
Orange County Fire Authority.
Other systems in Taiwan and Mexico rely on
measurements of the peak ground motion associated with
the S wave to relay warnings to locations far from an
earthquake's epicenter but still vulnerable to shaking.
DEPLOYMENT OF SYSTEM MAY STILL BE A LONG WAY
OFF
Allen and Kanamori used data from past
earthquakes to simulate their system. They are now
testing it on earthquakes that shake the region to
determine if it can provide accurate estimates in real
time. There are no immediate plans to develop an actual
warning system.
If developed, it would work best if plugged into a
region's infrastructure, allowing it to automatically
prompt shutdowns of everything from trains to factories
during major quakes, Allen said.
The study may settle the question of whether
earthquakes of different magnitudes begin in different
ways, said Lucy Jones, of the U.S. Geological Survey
office in Pasadena. The study suggests they do.
"There's debate whether quakes start differently or
if a 6 is just a 2 that doesn't stop," said Jones.
Measuring magnitude is the key to the success of any
warning system relying on P waves, said professor Lisa
Grant, an earthquake geologist at the University of
California, Irvine, who was not involved in the study.
Southern California is aswarm with tiny earthquakes that
go unnoticed, except by sensors, and cause no
damage.
"That's the trick," she said. "You don't want it to
trip on a small earthquake P wave.
"You have to detect the P wave, analyze it, estimate
magnitude and then, if it crosses a certain threshold,
send out a warning. Then the warning has to be received.
All of this has to happen in
seconds."